Biden has given reasons for approving the
Willow oil drilling project,
but they are fallacious.
Allegedly the attempt to reject the project entirely is likely to be
overturned by courts. What if that is true? What would be the right
thing to do?
We are dealing with a threat to kill most human beings and wipe out
most living species -- in effect, the biggest war in all history.
So let's look at it like a battle against the planet-roasters.
When your army holds a position that it cannot continue to hold
indefinitely, should you pull those troops back promptly, or hold the
position as long as possible? It depends on what you can gain by
holding it and what you might lose.
In this case, there is nothing to lose by fighting in court except the
cost of paying some lawyers. Therefore, Biden's duty is to hold that
position for as long as possible. Delaying the drilling is good in
itself, and the fight to delay it will inspire climate defenders and
help win the next election.
The delay also creates an opportunity for the situation to change. In
2025 it may be possible to pass a law — perhaps a carbon tax
— that would make Chevron abandon the project.