Adopted contact-tracing app
mardi 21 juillet 2020 à 02:00Ireland has released a contact-tracing app that people there have adopted.
The basic approach seems to be ethical. My tentative judgment is that I would be willing to participate in a contact-tracing system which worked that way, if I could do so without running a nonfree app or a portable phone.
For instance, if it were a stand-alone device with no network connection except bluetooth and doing nothing except this job, and I could examine and understand all the data it gives me to send in, and no software would ever be installed into it, I could treat it like my microwave oven — meaning that I don't care how it works inside. I could envision that the user gets the data out via USB, in a well-documented trasparent format, then sends it to the health department through a web site that does not send Javascript code to the browser.
The design principle here should be to infringe people's privacy in the minimal possible way that can succeed in stopping transmission of Covid-19.
It is our duty to cooperate with that vital goal — just as it is our duty to protect others by wearing masks — and society's duty to avoid asking us to make any additional, avoidable sacrifices of privacy.