*Yes, TikTok sucks. But the rules for
tech giants must be better than
"it's only bad if China does it."*
I think countries can indeed be safer by barring antisocial media
platforms that accumulate data for adversary countries.
It is true that this also helps dictatorships block the influence of
anyone from outside the dictator's power. But dictators already do
that, as it suits them, So I don't think this is a valid argument
about what a free country should do.
However, it is equally dangerous for a "domestic" company to collect
lots of personal data about people, with which to manipulate and
control them. And using peer pressure to make almost everyone
"consent" is not an excuse. We need to protect American minors, and
American adults, from Facebook and Ex-Twitter as well as Lies Social,
and to do it in a way that respects freedom of speech.
My proposal is to require recommendation engines to be independent
from platforms, using a standard protocol, so that any user can choose
to send an edited subset of per viewing history on any platform to any
recommendation engine, anonymously. then choose to follow (or not)
some or all of the recommendation.