US citizens: phone your senators to oppose the "EARN-IT" bill that
would prohibit end-to-end encryption and require most online services
to scan, for the government, all material they get from users.
That's what Congress is considering
once again, after it was shelved
for public opposition in 2020. Now they are trying to rush it.
I think this would require services to require users to run nonfree
software in order to use them.
The bill is so extreme that if people communicate through an encrypted
service, and then commit a crime, that would be grounds to prosecute
the service. Why go off the deep end? I speculate that they figure
to drop them (as a "compromise") while keeping the basic outrages.
I found a campaign to contact senators to oppose this bill, but I
can't use it or recommend it, because it requires running nonfree
Javascript code. Web sites and services should be usable with
Javascript disabled.
Why not make an exception and run the nonfree software "for a good
cause"? Because once you make that kind of exception, once you allow
a pervasive injustice to become part of how you fight other
injustices, you've effectively legitimized that one.
Those web sites could have been designed to function even with Javascript
disabled, and they should be.
The Capitol Switchboard numbers are
+1-202-224-3121,
+1-888-818-6641 and
+1-888-355-3588.
If you phone, please spread the word!