A campaign seeks to demonize the idea of taking a photo of a woman on
a public street without asking for her permission first.
As is common, the campaign operates by insisting that its position
is already generally accepted, and only "creeps" would disagree.
The campaign demands this right only for women and says nothing about
whether men should have it too. If it stands for gender bias, it is
clearly wrong.
But what if this right applies equally to everyone, regardless of
gender? Then it would not be prima facie unjust. Would it be a
change for the better?
If this right applies to use of machines that systematically take
photos of everyone, we could insist that people stop their Amazon
"ring" surveillance cameras from taking our pictures as we walk down
the street. Likewise for other surveillance cameras.
It would also prohibit "dashcams" mounted on vehicles that
continuously record the scene in front. These cameras can be a form
of surveillance, and perhaps their use should be regulated, but
prohibiting them entirely seems to be going too far.
If the thug that murdered George Floyd had had this right, he could
have ordered the witnesses to stop making video recordings of what he
was doing to Floyd. Thugs would just love to have that power.
Indeed, they often threaten, attack or frame people that record what
they are doing. In Spain they got the right-wing government to
criminalize it.
However, it would be legitimate to exclude thugs from this right -- to
declare that, because of their special legal powers, they are not
entitled to the same rights of privacy that most people deserve.
However, I cannot willingly give up the right of everyone to take
photos of scenes in public. Every scene in a city or park is likely
to have people in it, even if they are not the reason you take the
photo. Probably some are so far that you couldn't possibly ask them
for permission, or recognize them with the naked eye, though may you
could recognize them by scene enhancement on a photo. There may also
be dozens who are much closer, You could hardly take a photo of a
monument, a building, a sculpture or a cityscape if you had to get
permission from everyone in the scene.