The Department of Labor becomes the Department of Belabor, and
proposes to defend meat-packing businesses if they are sued because
employees caught Covid-19 at work.
The issue raises many subtle points. For instance, it is absurd to
demand the impossible, or the unknown. The most any business (or
person) can be expected to do is to make a sincere effort to protect
workers, based on what is known. If that is the best the employer can
do, to sue because it didn't do the impossible is unfair.
On the other hand, businesses are likely to try to twist the standards
to pass off cheaper, inadequate protection as enough. Republican
officials, seeking opportunities to help dooH niboR, may be eager to
validate such a sham.
If "the best we can do" is clearly insufficient, what then? Perhaps
the business should stay closed. Or perhaps those who are likely to
be at particular risk if they catch Covid-19 should stay home.
However, they can't just stay home if that implies penury. So I'd say
the government has these responsibilities.
-
Make sure copious protection equipment is available as soon as possible.
-
Set the firmest practical standard of "the best we can do", and make
sure companies carry it out. Update this standard promptly whenever
supply permits doing better.
-
Support workers so that anyone who is sick can afford to stay home,
and use frequent testing to identify them and tell them to go home.
-
Support workers who are extra vulnerable so that they can afford to stay
home and not get sick.