Arguing against a sale of rhino horn from farmed rhinos.
I don't know whether this argument is valid, overall.
I agree that the sale is really intended to be illegally exported.
Does that mean it is wrong? Being illegal does not imply something is
wrong. Exporting poached rhino horn is wrong because it is leading to
extinction of rhinos, but whether exporting farmed rhino horn is wrong
is a different question. Indeed, that is the crucial question here.
A sufficiently large supply of farmed rhino horn, together with a
fairly effective anti-poaching program, ought in principle to drive
poachers out of business. But that depends on making the
anti-poaching program effective enough to drive up the cost of poached
rhino horn, and a large enough supply of farmed rhino horn to drive
down the price they can charge. Is that feasible to achieve? I don't
know.
Counterpropaganda against the medical myths about rhino horn is
clearly a good thing to do.